How do you actually change lawyers in an injury case?

Almost every page on this subject tells you to send a letter and stops there. The useful answer is who sends it, and the order things happen in — because doing it in the wrong order is the one way to make this harder than it needs to be.

Tell us about your case

or call 1-866-568-4913

The decision is usually the hard part and people spend weeks on it. The mechanics, once decided, are routine — and they are mostly not your work. The thing worth getting right is the sequence.

The order of operations

Five steps. Only two of them are yours.

1. Consult the new firm before you end anything. A consultation is confidential and is not a termination. Bring the fee agreement, the Statement of Client's Rights you signed, any correspondence, and anything you have signed since. The new firm cannot tell you where you stand without the contract that defines it.
2. Sign with the new firm. This is the moment that matters, because from here you are never unrepresented. Everything after it is handled between the two firms.
3. The new firm gives notice to the old one. You do not need to make that phone call, and you do not need to write that letter. The notice tells the first firm the representation has ended and asks for the file.
4. The file moves, and the first firm states its claim. Expect a letter asserting a charging lien. That is routine and it is not a bill you pay personally in a contingency case.
5. If a lawsuit is already filed, counsel is substituted on the record. Paperwork between the firms and the court. Your part is usually a signature.

Why the order matters

Fire first and you are, for however long it takes to find someone, a person with an open injury claim and no lawyer. Deadlines do not pause while you look. Insurers do not stop asking for things. And you have lost the leverage of being able to say no to the second firm, because by then you need them.

Consulting first costs nothing and commits you to nothing. There is no rule requiring you to end one relationship before exploring another, and no firm you consult will tell your current one.

What the outgoing firm is required to do

Rule 4-1.16(d) is short and it is the whole of the obligation:

Upon termination of representation, a lawyer shall take steps to the extent reasonably practicable to protect a client's interest, such as giving reasonable notice to the client, allowing time for employment of other counsel, surrendering papers and property to which the client is entitled, and refunding any advance payment of fee or expense that has not been earned or incurred. The lawyer may retain papers and other property relating to or belonging to the client to the extent permitted by law.

Most pages on this subject quote the first sentence and stop. The second one is also there, and pretending otherwise sets people up for a surprise. A lawyer may retain some materials, to the extent the law permits — a retaining lien. In practice an incoming firm deals with this regularly and it rarely becomes a fight, but you should hear it here rather than in a letter. What the file actually contains and what you are entitled to is its own page.

What you personally have to do

Less than people expect.

If a firm you are considering tells you that writing the termination letter is your job, that is worth noticing. Handling the handover is part of taking the case.

What the notice has to accomplish

We are not going to tell you what to write, because drafting it is legal work and the incoming firm does it. What is useful to understand is what it has to do:

• End the representation clearly, so there is no ambiguity about who acts for you from what date.
• Be dated and provable. The date can matter later if anyone argues about what work was done before or after it.
• Ask for the file, which starts the clock on the obligation in Rule 4-1.16(d).
• Say where the file goes, so nothing sits waiting for an address.

Keep a copy of whatever goes out. Your new firm will, but a second copy costs nothing.

Deadlines, insurers, and anything already in motion

• The claim's deadlines do not change because the lawyer did. They attach to the claim, not the firm. This is the strongest argument for consulting early rather than drifting.
• The insurer is notified by the new firm. Adjusters deal with this constantly.
• Anything scheduled stays scheduled unless somebody moves it. If a deposition or mediation is on the calendar, say so in the first conversation — it changes how quickly the handover has to happen.
• If a suit is filed, the court has a real role. Rule 2.505(e)(3) of the Florida Rules of General Practice and Judicial Administration makes a substitution effective on [f]iling of a written order by the court, that reflects written consent of the client, and the court may condition substitution of counsel upon payment of or grant of security for the substituted attorney's fees and expenses or upon such other terms as may be just. That is the part other pages leave out: in litigation a judge can attach terms to the change. Separately, Rule 4-1.16(c) can require a lawyer to keep going until released. How much that matters depends on where the case is, and the stage your case is at is what decides whether it is too late.
• If anything has been signed — a release, a settlement agreement, an authorization you do not remember — bring it. It is the single thing most likely to change the advice.

How long it takes

The decision takes as long as it takes. The mechanics are usually quick: signing with a new firm happens in one appointment, notice goes out the same day or the next, and the file follows over the following weeks depending on how organized the first firm is and how big the file has become. Nothing about your claim is on hold while that happens, because the new firm is already acting for you from the day you sign.

What slows it down is almost always one of three things: a file nobody can locate quickly, a dispute about the lien, or a client who waited until a deadline was close before starting.

Common questions

Do I have to write a letter to fire my lawyer?

In practice the incoming firm sends the notice. Drafting it is legal work and it is part of what you are hiring them to do. What matters is that the notice is clear, dated and asks for the file.

Should I fire my lawyer before or after I find a new one?

After. Signing with the new firm first means you are never without representation while deadlines run. A consultation beforehand is confidential and is not a termination.

Who tells the insurance company?

The new firm. It is routine and adjusters handle it constantly.

Does my old firm have to hand over the file?

Rule 4-1.16(d) requires a lawyer, on termination, to take steps reasonably practicable to protect the client's interest, including surrendering papers and property to which the client is entitled. The same subdivision also allows the lawyer to retain materials to the extent permitted by law, which is the part most pages leave out.

What is a substitution of counsel?

If a lawsuit has been filed, the change is made on the court record by a written order reflecting your written consent — Rule 2.505(e)(3). The firms prepare it and you sign. The same rule lets the court condition the substitution, including on payment of or security for the previous attorney's fees, so the closer a case is to trial the less routine it becomes.

Will changing lawyers delay my case?

Usually not much, because the new firm is acting from the day you sign. Delay comes from a file that is slow to arrive or a deadline that was already close.

Will I get a bill from my old firm?

In a contingency case you do not pay a discharged lawyer out of pocket. The firm asserts a claim against the eventual recovery, capped at the fee in the contract you signed — the money page works through it.

Can I change lawyers more than once?

Nothing prohibits it, but each change adds a claim against the same recovery, and a case that has moved firms repeatedly is harder for the next firm to take. If you are considering a second change, that is a conversation to have openly in the consultation.